alftn":2atl6zay said:Texas, montana, aussie, new zealand, S. America, S. Africa, in wide open spaces ,,,I can understand why Horned animals might be better......
andybob":j490r1u4 said:alftn":j490r1u4 said:Texas, montana, aussie, new zealand, S. America, S. Africa, in wide open spaces ,,,I can understand why Horned animals might be better......
Which is why some breeds from the harshest African environments, including carnivours (leopards on my Ranch) are polled?
Leopold":36rcm5xs said:I am sold, BUT I am horribly biased regarding all 5 true longhorn breeds and wouldn't let a poll animal in my paddock. Stay interested you are right to be fascinated.
Keren":2dladnf0 said:dun":2dladnf0 said:Keep in mind I get strange thoughts! I wonder if the Shorthorn and Longhorn in britain were developed at the same time. Or if the Shorthorn was derived from them to get rid of some of the horn span.
I get your point, I just wondered about using these to get back to the old style shorthorns - I love shorthorns but the ones we have here now are extreme framed, very rangey, long legged, narrow gutted, fine boned, hard keeping types. Of course, thats a generalisation and I'm sure you would find the type I like (moderate frame, deep, easy keeping) if you looked hard enough.
Udders and heavy fronts aside, you've just gotta admire these cows for their depth and sheer capacity. I just wondered if anyone had had anything to do with them personally. Heck I dont even know if I can get any in Australia.
We had Shorthorns back in the 70s and they were great cows. When we moved to MO and decided to "unretire" again I looked high and low for some good Shorthorn cows. Went to Shorthorn sales all over the place and found thse giant cows that more resembled Holsteins in frame then the cows we had. Eded up going with Red Angus as our base (this time)trevorgreycattleco":1ye5u7tu said:keren, I feel your pain on the shorthorns! I won't even tell you how much money I have waisted on the wrong genetics with this breed. I went from 55 mama cows to 5 because of the problems you described. all the mainstream sires, trump, Rodeo drive, waukaru sires are all huged framed vacum cleaner! I have located some people that raise awesome shorthorns. Rob Sneed in Missouri, Sue McClaughlin in Michigan are two that come to mind. easy keeping, moderate framed cows that flat get the job done. Had to see them with my own eyes to believe it. I now run a bull from Rob sneed. 69 lb birthweight with a 580 ww no creep. Had a rea of 1.25 per 100 lbs body weight. Th and PHA free. He is a heavily linebred bull. Rob has not used any mainstream sires in a long time. He is truly what the shorthorn breed needs if it is ever to make any advances in the commercial sector. I hope this helped a little bit.