If you're Showing in a Commercial class, take #2 first, #1 second. Don't expect #1 to do too well as a cow. #2 might work OK.
If you are looking for Cows; particularly Show Calf producers, take #3 first, followed by #4. Don't expect either of them to do too well showing in a Commercial Breed Class.
Pretty easy to analyze from such good pictures. A good eye should be able to see beyond the grooming and fitting.