First, either is fine.
2 seems to be more compact, a bit beefier, I like his sire Pistol Pete better than him
1 appears to have more length and I think you'll get more milk from his daughters than 2 (Liberty)
I don't know anything about 1's pedigree, but I'll guess a shade better calving ease, though neither should be a problem
depends a bit on what your cows need too.
I'd go with 1... because ya get more belt per square inch and everyone knows the belt is the tastiest part.
Who is number 1 ?
He reminds me a bit of Unique, but I don't recognize him.
Maybe that's why I like 1 over 2 as I prefer Unique offspring over Liberty's.
Can you tell us any more?
p.s.
I don't want to knock Liberty, I saw a daughter out of a crossbred cow that I liked.
You probably know Valor (I don't like his head) but I liked a couple calves I saw from him.