A little background first. This breeder I have known for years, He raises outstanding Brangus on a place here in north GA, Has a couple of champion bulls that people buy semen from, and several high-dollar cows she flushes. In recent years, he has produced some great Ultra black bulls as well, using top Angus sires in the country.
He also has about 1200 acres in middle Ga, south of I-16, where he keeps a herd of about 200 purebred Brangus cows..and about 150 registered Brahma cows. With these, he has been custom raising (I guess you'd call it) replacement heifers for people on contract. He produces mostly fI Braford and f! Black Braford heifers with the Brahmas, He AI's with sexed semen to get a high percentage of heifers. I think someone told me you can get about 80% accuracy with sexed semen, So if you wanted 20 heifers, he'd AI about 25-30 of the cows. You pay a deposit per heifer you order,and pay the rest when the calf is 6 mos old. He mostly produces black baldy heifers from the Brangus cows. Same deal..AI's them with Hereford or Black Hereford sexed semen. The few Braford or baldy steers he gets when he does this, always sell well.
A few years ago, he AI'd about 50 of the Brama cows with sexed Chi-Angus semen, and about 50 with sexed homo for black and polled, Simmental semen. He then bred the f1 Black Simbrah to Chi-Angus bulls, and the f1 Ch-Ang x Brahmas to the Black Simm bulls. Both of these c rosses produce excellent cows. They end up with about as much ear and leather as a Brangus. And the steers grow so fast you can almost see it day to day. All of this is good. Great even. But, he left some of the calves bulls. Not something I would use for breeding at all. He has been breeding some the ½ Simm.1/4 Br 1/4 Chiangus cows to the ½ ChiAng, ¼ Br ¼ Simmm bulls and vice versa., to create I guess his own 1/4Brahma, 3/8 ChiAngus, 3/8ths Black Simm composite breed. They made decent enough cows. But I don't see the advantage in them over the f2 cows. A little less ear and leather maybe, but don't see as how this brings any more hybrid vigor than the f2 cross did. AND he has left some of those calves bulls, and wants to send us 2 of them for our 150 Braford and f1 Hereford/Brahmas!. .
He has done the same thing with some of his Brangus herd. He bred about 50 to Chi-Angus and 50 to homo polled black Simmental bulls. Got sort of a Mega or Super Ultrablack cow, which sells very well, And those steers always top the sales He then bred the f1 Brangus/Chi-Angus cows back to the Black Simm bulls, and the Brangus/Black Simms back to the Chi-Angus bulls. And THESE made hellacious cows.. very little trace of ear or leather now. He can sell the heifers ahead of time like he does his f1Brafords. And the steers out grow and out sell the f1s. BUT...he left some of those bull calves intact, and is doing the same thing, creating a 1/4Brangus/3/8black Simm/3/8 Chi-Angus composite "breed". Again, don't see any improvement over the f2 cows, and would NOT want to buy a bull like this for breeding. He is sending us 2 of those!
Now for the kicker..he breeding the Brahma influenced composites with the Brangus influenced composites, for God;s sakes! And he is sending 2 of THOSE mutt bulls to us! Well, not my cows, not my circus and not my monkeys!! Well, free bulls and the man has signed an agreement to pay $900 for every heifer calf as soon as it is born and pick them up at 6 mos old. And I suppose the black baldy steers my client gets will sell as well as any other at 6 mos old. Just probably won't be as big as the ones we would have got from the Brangus or Ultrablack bulls I was recommending.
So, opinions please?
He also has about 1200 acres in middle Ga, south of I-16, where he keeps a herd of about 200 purebred Brangus cows..and about 150 registered Brahma cows. With these, he has been custom raising (I guess you'd call it) replacement heifers for people on contract. He produces mostly fI Braford and f! Black Braford heifers with the Brahmas, He AI's with sexed semen to get a high percentage of heifers. I think someone told me you can get about 80% accuracy with sexed semen, So if you wanted 20 heifers, he'd AI about 25-30 of the cows. You pay a deposit per heifer you order,and pay the rest when the calf is 6 mos old. He mostly produces black baldy heifers from the Brangus cows. Same deal..AI's them with Hereford or Black Hereford sexed semen. The few Braford or baldy steers he gets when he does this, always sell well.
A few years ago, he AI'd about 50 of the Brama cows with sexed Chi-Angus semen, and about 50 with sexed homo for black and polled, Simmental semen. He then bred the f1 Black Simbrah to Chi-Angus bulls, and the f1 Ch-Ang x Brahmas to the Black Simm bulls. Both of these c rosses produce excellent cows. They end up with about as much ear and leather as a Brangus. And the steers grow so fast you can almost see it day to day. All of this is good. Great even. But, he left some of the calves bulls. Not something I would use for breeding at all. He has been breeding some the ½ Simm.1/4 Br 1/4 Chiangus cows to the ½ ChiAng, ¼ Br ¼ Simmm bulls and vice versa., to create I guess his own 1/4Brahma, 3/8 ChiAngus, 3/8ths Black Simm composite breed. They made decent enough cows. But I don't see the advantage in them over the f2 cows. A little less ear and leather maybe, but don't see as how this brings any more hybrid vigor than the f2 cross did. AND he has left some of those calves bulls, and wants to send us 2 of them for our 150 Braford and f1 Hereford/Brahmas!. .
He has done the same thing with some of his Brangus herd. He bred about 50 to Chi-Angus and 50 to homo polled black Simmental bulls. Got sort of a Mega or Super Ultrablack cow, which sells very well, And those steers always top the sales He then bred the f1 Brangus/Chi-Angus cows back to the Black Simm bulls, and the Brangus/Black Simms back to the Chi-Angus bulls. And THESE made hellacious cows.. very little trace of ear or leather now. He can sell the heifers ahead of time like he does his f1Brafords. And the steers out grow and out sell the f1s. BUT...he left some of those bull calves intact, and is doing the same thing, creating a 1/4Brangus/3/8black Simm/3/8 Chi-Angus composite "breed". Again, don't see any improvement over the f2 cows, and would NOT want to buy a bull like this for breeding. He is sending us 2 of those!
Now for the kicker..he breeding the Brahma influenced composites with the Brangus influenced composites, for God;s sakes! And he is sending 2 of THOSE mutt bulls to us! Well, not my cows, not my circus and not my monkeys!! Well, free bulls and the man has signed an agreement to pay $900 for every heifer calf as soon as it is born and pick them up at 6 mos old. And I suppose the black baldy steers my client gets will sell as well as any other at 6 mos old. Just probably won't be as big as the ones we would have got from the Brangus or Ultrablack bulls I was recommending.
So, opinions please?