Either one of these any good? Comments Welcome
- Thread starter jscunn
- Start date
Help Support CattleToday:
jscunn
Well-known member
Robert is not playing fair, he is getting inside information. It will be interesting to see who the favorite is we people get to see them live and in person. I still think the top one brings more money.
I'm willing to bet 99% of the difference is the pose and the depth of the stalk bedding, if you transpose the bottom bull over the top bull there is zero difference in 'depth' it is all perception. I will also bet that if these bulls sell to people who are actually at the sale rather than buying off of a photo on the internet they will sell pretty close to each other. They are, in my never to be humble opinion, a decent pair of bulls but a classic example of how 'good' photographs can really sell an animal.
ALACOWMAN
Well-known member
not playing fair, and being condescending at the same time.... get that alot on herejscunn":2ib5zoai said:
ALACOWMAN":1ase9q5w said:
The fact that he knows something doesn't make him condescending. Maybe sarcastic :shock: but not condescending :lol2:
Based on what I "know" I am going to reverse myself and say that #2 could easily end up bringing more, and I picked #1.
ALACOWMAN
Well-known member
does'nt matter what he know to me,,, no one has claimed to be a expert... just gave opinions
pdfangus
Well-known member
personally I don't care.
I made my comments based upon what I could see....
I still see the same....
there are a lot of other factors I would have wanted if I was writing a check. but just looking at a photo.....
it is what it is.
I started out by saying they both would work.
I made my comments based upon what I could see....
I still see the same....
there are a lot of other factors I would have wanted if I was writing a check. but just looking at a photo.....
it is what it is.
I started out by saying they both would work.
#1- CC&7 ?
jscunn
Well-known member
Robert,
Come on they are ankle deep in corn stalks, of course they are from the midwest.
Chuckie
Not my bulls, very nice bulls thou.
2 different bulls tonight.
Come on they are ankle deep in corn stalks, of course they are from the midwest.
Chuckie
Not my bulls, very nice bulls thou.
2 different bulls tonight.
jscunn
Well-known member
Guys I am just having some fun with robert and he knows it.. he knows where the bulls are from and has been sworn to secrecy just like I have. The owner just wants opinions on the bulls. Ignore mine and robert banter it is all in good fun.. right robert ?
ALACOWMAN
Well-known member
i like both,,, #2 could bring more. .. im sure i cant afford either...if you have seen my cattle you'd have to wonder,, why i had the gall to comment in the first place :cowboy:
jscunn
Well-known member
Two more same age, born in the Feburary - March of 2011. Pictured in January 2012..
1066
1082
Comments?
1066
1082
Comments?
limftw
Well-known member
definitely not in the same tier as the first two you posted...
ALACOWMAN
Well-known member
yeap still impressed with the geographic location of the first bull :cowboy:limftw":btqgdp5h said:
Jake
Well-known member
Not much to like about the fourth bull. Looks like the NCAA tourney play in games. Two lesser 16 seeds facing off to get stomped by the 1 seeds posted in the beginning
Well the corn stalks are much deeper on #4 but it doesn't hide his weak top so I would pick 3 over 4 dang Scott if you start asking for reasons will you take into account how many years it has been for me lol
Gizmom
Gizmom
Jeanne - Simme Valley
Well-known member
I don't like the hind legs on #3
