Caustic Burno":1eue0w8l said:
Brandonm2":1eue0w8l said:
Caustic Burno":1eue0w8l said:
East Caney":1eue0w8l said:
Every breed can be a hobby breed. It's not the breed, it's the owner of the cattle.
Running cattle that don't fit the environment (and give you the best return on your investment) doesn't make it a hobby, it just doesn't make business sense. Again, it goes back to the owner. You may as well buy something you can stand to look at. It's like any other job...you might take a pay cut if you're more happy at that job. I can stand to look at Beefmasters (because I believe they'll give me the best return on my investment - time and money), so that's what I'm raising.
Caustic,
Regarding the influence of Brahman cattle in the American beef industry, you may as well save the energy it takes to press your fingers to the keyboard. Some people simply have no understanding and can't see out of the box they live in.
Aint that the truth go to any salebarn in the south and watch the cattle come through doesn't take a NASA scientist to spot the ear or dew lap. But it does take a Cattleman.
You could be right about Texas(I haven't been to the state six times), you are right about Louisiana and probably Florida, and I admit that I have not spent enough time in Tennessee, Arkansas, Georgia, Virginia, and South Carolina to even have an opinion; but in Alabama (particularly North Alabama) I would tag maybe 25% of the cattle at the barn as being Brahman based IF you base it on seedstock producers that advertise with the Alabama Cattlemen's Assn, Alabama has 36 Angus breeders, 21 Charolais breeders, 14 Simmental breeders, 12 Hereford breeders, 10 Senepol breeders, 7 Red Angus breeders, 6 Limousin breeders, and 5 Gelbvieh breeders versus just 3 Brahman breeders, 10 Brangus breeders, 7 Santa Gertrudis breeders and 9 Beefmaster breeders. That is 111 Bos Taurus to 29 Bos Indicus which is pretty suggestive of the 25% number I am guessing in the commercial sector. 20 years ago Beefmaster and Gert were both about as common down here as Angus were. That is not the case now. Brangus is the only Brahman composite that seems to really still have momentum now.
http://www.bamabeef.org/NewCattleBreede ... .htm#Angus
Open up a copy of the Alabama Farmer's Bulletin. You can get Brahmans, Gerts, and Branguses; but most of the ads are for Angus and Charolais
You named 25% of the seedstock producers are running Brimmers. When you drive down the road how many of those commercial cattlemen are using a Char/Angus/Hereford/Simm on a Brimmer momma crossbred cow. You can bet it's a lot.
It is easy to drive down the road and spot the man raising cattle for money and those that have welfare cattle.
Its just like the profit thread that Stepper started on the beginners board that has been avoided like the plauge, most ain't making it. That is a hard pill to swallow.
It is like the longhorn boys saying the breed is it, it aint now if you took that longhorn cow and put a Polled Hereford or Angus bull on them knocked off the horns , came back with a Brangus or Char on those crossbred mommas you would get something of value. Nothing wrong with running your breed of choice just don't try and sell these beginners on here they are going to turn a profit with novelity cattle or cattle not suited to produce maximum pounds in there operating enviroment. This is where kittens are trying to BS a tomcat.
If Alabama commercial cattle had pedigrees, most of them here probably have a Gert or a Beefmaster bull somewhere back on the bottom side and there is more than one Hereford farther back than that and if you could take it all the back to the 40s or 30s you would run into a number with Jersey ancestry. Around here Brahman is fading into the past. They take a significant dock at the salebarn here THOUGH the mature F1 type cows have always brought well. You can argue that the Bos indicus cattle are better adapted to this climate all you want to; but there are a lot of Bos taurus cows around here breeding back and weaning 550 pound (and more) calves year in and year out and some of them are even (gasp) Angus!!! Straight Angus bulls match and even outperform Brangus and Gert bulls on performance test after performance test.....despite the heat. IF I were raising cattle in BRAZIL yes I would probably have a Nellore cow herd or some other Bos Indicus based breed; but Alabama.....at least from Montgomery North does not get a lot of benefit from eared cattle.
I can throw more evidence out there
The 2006 Wiregrass Bull sale open to BCIA members with any breed and this is waaay down there near the Florida line.
Angus, Chars, Simmies, Simmies crosses (most of them Angus crosses), and a Lim.
http://www.albcia.org/wiregrassbullsale2006.html
The EPD Bull sale down in Letohatchee. Again open to any breeder that wanted to consign a bull or two
Angus, Charolais, Simmental, Chiangus, and Hereford
http://www.albcia.org/AL-BCIA-2007-EPD.pdf
Go to the Cullman North Alabama Bull Sale (~my part of the state)
Angus, Charolais, Simmental, and Chiangus
http://www.albcia.org/2006_NA_AU_Catalog.pdf