Back in the early summer, I was looking to buy another 38. I liked the S&W 442 cause my wife has had one for years, but I also liked the new LCR. I couldn't decide which one of the 2 that I like best, so I bought both of them.
As far as the 442, there's not much to say, they are an excellent revolver. Well made, time proven.
The LCR is a new type of revolver, a bit lighter (couple of ounces) and Ruger makes a good firearm. I believe my eyes like the sights on the LCR better.
Its a tossup, each revolver is a great firearm. Each has there own finer points over the other. I am proud to own each one.