cowgal
Well-known member
AAOK":1340oopr said:
Sixteen years ago, we pulled the nicest Polled Hereford heifer of the lot out of my Father-in-laws herd for my eight year old daughter to show. We did everything the "experts" said to do, and after three shows, realized that pasture cows can't compete on the Show Circuit. Now, this is only a hobby for me. I knew up front that I would probably never show a profit, however, I'm still trying. In my opinion, show cattle (breeding stock), are what pasture cows would be in a perfect world. Sure, they're babied. My cows are all fed a show ration 365 days a year. They are my pets. They all have a name and a show ring history with lots of memories. When we lose a cow, we don't even think of the monetary loss. We feel as though we've lost a member of the family.
All this said, I think the commercial cattleman can learn a great deal from the Show Ring. If he can study and learn genetics, he can AI his best cows to the proper "Show Bulls" and produce some superior calves that will go out in the pasture and work!! :shock:
If your best pasture cattle won't work in a show ring, why should I believe your best show cattle will work in the pasture. You say that show cattle are what pasture cattle would be in a perfect world. Well, this isn't a perfect world and producers want performers whether it be pasture or show ring--I thought you said first that you couldn't acheive both (hereford reference) then that you were working to produce something that commercial cattlemen could benefit from. If this is your goal then I think that is great, but I was asking for convincing, because an animal on show feed 365 is not pushed to meet commercial value potential.
If you are saying that MY attitude won't last here, then I am sorry that I provoked any critical thinking skills. Not trying to stir the pot, I am just trying to initiate intelligent conversation.