Ok--I'll play. I grew up as a kid that weighed 90lbs--tall and scrawny, had an identical twin brother, and we would fight till neither of us could stand anymore. I raised 3 sons too, so I have a bit of experience in the boy at school thing.
I haven't been privy to what has happened before this incident, but from just reading this thread, there seems to be some precedent.
With boys, bulls, dogs, and alligators, there's gonna be a peckin' order set of the alpha male type thing--always, since the dawn of time.
2 things jump out at me in these posts:
(1)
not to hit first, but to hit last.
(2)
Well this other kid,... came up and sucker punched my son in his right eye.
(3)
I am demanding this other kid be expelled
1. You tied your son's hands for the 1st 1-2 punches. That, is historically a failed strategy for kids, adults, and sovereign nations. Think about it.
2. Sucker punch or free punch--what's the difference? You basically told your son he has to stand there and take the first haymaker gratis.
Ouch! Kinda hard to throw the last punch when the 1st one was essentially both the 1st and last one. Harder still when the first one (a freebie) leaves ya layin on the ground watchin the stars go round in your head. IOW, there is NO difference in a sucker punch and a free punch unless the intent is to run from the free punch and I don't think that was your intentions when telling your son those now questionable words of wisdom. It hasn't been that long ago I heard the leader of the most powerful nation on the planet tell the rest of the world we would never be the first to use nuclear weapons, thus giving them the first punch free of charge. Our potential enemies must have grinned broadly and slept soundly in their beds that night. We better hope that first punch isn't a knockout punch..
(3) You want the kid expelled. Ok--big deal--he left school anyway and probably won't give a crap one way or another if he ever returns or not. You ever read or see
Helter Skelter the Charles Manson story? Manson had been in and out of prison his whole life and knew the ins and outs of prison life. At the very end, after he had been sentenced to life in prison, he just shrugged and said to the prosecutor:
"If you give a man the whip and he likes the whip--what have you really done to him?"
If my father had told me I had to take the 1st punch I'd probably never went back to school. I got my butt kicked lots of times, but I never had to fight the same person twice.
I believe in 3 things--in this order, and they apply to all aspects of our lives:
STAND! (this, is non-negotiable--EVER)
Don't start no crap there won't be no crap.
You want to start crap, I'm of the opinion that the best defense is an absolutely overwhelming offense.
Best of luck to ya in this, but I honestly think you should rethink #1, because eventually, your son is most certainly going to anyway. He ain't gonna stand there and take that 1st punch his whole life--I guarantee that!