Bright Raven
Well-known member
Jogeephus":2nloc0w2 said:Arsenic is one of the most common elements in our soil and many animals need it to grow properly. There are also two types of arsenic. Organic and inorganic. I believe the inorganic is the most toxic. CCA was made from the less toxic type. My take is that anything, including water, is toxic if you get enough of it.
Very good grasshopper. ;-)
Going a step farther. There are many species of inorganic arsenic. BTW: the term species is also applicable to chemistry and refers to the different inorganic compounds that include the arsenic atom. In a pure sense, there is only one arsenic - elemental arsenic (As) on the periodic table. When one says there is more than one arsenic, they mean it comes combined with different other elements to form a compound of arsenic.
People wonder why EPA has to do site specific risk assessments when cleaning up contamination. It is because every site contains different forms or compounds of arsenic.
It gets very complex.
Edited to add: toxicity is not only a function of concentration. It is also a function of bioavailability. A very high concentration can be less toxic than a much lower concentration if the higher concentration is not readily bioavailable.