Possible Beef Checkoff increase

Why increase it when the funds received could be better managed? Or should we give more just to be mismanaged
 
hooknline":33pzieea said:
Why increase it when the funds received could be better managed? Or should we give more just to be mismanaged
Not everyone believes it is mismanaged. ;-) Every opportunity I am given such as vacations trips to the city anywhere really, I ask people from non ag backgrounds what they know about beef. Their reply, BEEF it's what's for Dinner. That $5 charged to the producer used to market those 902# of beef was well spent.
 
alohacattle said:
Houston I think your missing the point or your math is indeed wrong.

In 1985 when they took the first checkoff out of the sellers check. The seller was maybe getting $65 for a 7 cwt feeder.

$455 - $1= $454

Now they are still taking $1 but the seller is selling that 7cwt steer for $138.

$966 - $1 = $965

Apples to apples the checkoff needs to be increased don't you think?



Perhaps, but my point is this. The value of that advertising dollars is less correct? That also means that that same dollar paid for a animal is less... Also just because we are getting more dollars per head now is no reason to charge more. Cause if that is your argument, Im owed a lot for when we were getting a whole lot less for many years!
 
houstoncutter":1l9okw1n said:
The value of that advertising dollars is less correct?
The value of the $1 taken out of the sellers check is the same, $1. However the % that $1 takes away from the Sale price is much less. Your animal is in no way worth less, it is worth far more than it ever was. The % taken from your check is the only thing that has decreased.
 
Except most animals get sold several times. I don't know if its always been that way since the check off started or not
 
hooknline":2u4g43yj said:
Except most animals get sold several times. I don't know if its always been that way since the check off started or not
On average they are sold 5 times, $5 collected by the National beef council to market 902# of beef is worth every penny.
 
alohacattle":3smxjpl4 said:
houstoncutter":3smxjpl4 said:
The value of that advertising dollars is less correct?
The value of the $1 taken out of the sellers check is the same, $1. However the % that $1 takes away from the Sale price is much less. Your animal is in no way worth less, it is worth far more than it ever was. The % taken from your check is the only thing that has decreased.[/quote



Lets try this another way, both the Check Off and the animal are paid for with dollars. If the value of the check off dollar is less, the value of the other is less as well, otherwise the value has not changed. What has changed is how much more the animal is bringing now, but if that is the deciding factor then all of the cattle producers have been cheated.

I remember no reduction in check off fees when good calves were bring about a 1/4 of what their bringing now. When you really get down to it we have been robbed for years with this program. It was supposed to be about promoting the sale of beef, not helping to pay for some guys degree in a land grant college!
 
My hope , that this cash grab will stir up the base of cattlemen. Maybe then we can come up with the signatures for a referendum to overturn this money grab for good.
 
Houston's math may or may not be correct or easy to understand, but his point about alot of money being taken away from family cattle people and used for inflated salaries and special projects for people on the "inside" is right on target. It was supposed to sell beef, and we have all read about different ways the money has been used for other purposes. Just like everything else, once a law allows money to be taken, that law is never overturned or the money given back. Just as has already been said----cattle prices are high at the moment, so they want to increase the tax. How many of you same people were fighting to get it reduced when the 500 lb calf was worth 40 cents per pound, not that many years ago? What will be in the new raise in the tax that says it will go back to 1 dollar when the cattle price goes down? No tax ever goes away. Like it has already been said, maybe this will create enough fury to get the signatures to get rid of it. But, more than likely, there will be another rule change to keep it around---there is precedence.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top