Do NGOs help or hinder?

Help Support CattleToday:

mtskylark

Member
Joined
Apr 6, 2017
Messages
12
Reaction score
0
I'm continuing my paper and nearing the end of the semester. I'm just looking for open opinions here.

How is cooperating with government and non-government organizations helping the rancher?
 

Lucky_P

Well-known member
Joined
May 21, 2009
Messages
3,300
Reaction score
260
Location
Western KY
All I know is that almost every time i participated in a 'government' program, it was fraught with all sorts of requirements that virtually doomed the practice to failure and necessitated that I come back after the fact and re-do it, correctly, at my own expense.
Additionally, it just gave them more opportunity to insert themselves into my business... I do not, anymore, pursue those 'government' dollars for any reason.
 

FiveOaksFarmGA

Active member
Joined
Mar 25, 2017
Messages
43
Reaction score
0
I looked into one of those USDA microloans once for an equipment purchase. They wanted more info than the banks, interest rate was higher, and processing time was in excess of 100 days. Highly ineffective for business purposes, so used NGO (John Deere Financial) to pay for the purchase with 0% interest. Have heard of others that have had good use of USDA loans, but not beneficial in my experience. Rarely does government solve a problem.
 
OP
M

mtskylark

Member
Joined
Apr 6, 2017
Messages
12
Reaction score
0
HDRider":3oexte84 said:
By NGO, do you mean non governmental organizations like PETA?

non-government organizations... not so much PETA, cause they're a pain in the arse. But orgs for example, the prairie conservation club(also a pain) is a big deal where i'm from. Maybe something you're more familiar with is National Fish and Wildlife Foundation, Nature Conservancy, or the World Nature Organization. So where I'm from the prairie conservation is pushing for more private land being sold off to the conservancy that will no longer allow cattle to graze on that land because they think the cattle cause erosion and plant degradation, so local ranchers are battling them to keep their land along with battling the BLM and their regulations, restrictions, and fees to use the land they share. I just wondered if anyone found these or some of these NGOs to be helpful. Someone mentioned that it may be more helpful with productivity but not so much profitability. Thoughts? I know there's a lot more that goes into it, but just a general opinion.
 
OP
M

mtskylark

Member
Joined
Apr 6, 2017
Messages
12
Reaction score
0
So what I'm seeing so far, is that whether its government or not, they're usually more a pain than they're worth? I'm a little bit familiar with BLM stuff. I didn't know John Deere offered stuff like that, so thats really good that you were able to utilize that! My paper has a lot of focus on land conservancy because that was the most talked about topic among research journals, dissertations and such, which were required references. Normally I don't delve too deep into this sort of stuff, so a lot of this info is new to me. I didn't see land conservation as such a battle, because in north central montana, its just what ranchers(farmers) do to maintain their herds/crops. if you don't take care of the land you can't take of anything else and your operation will fail. So.... these gov't and non-gov't orgs other than BLM, USFS, and a couple others I mentioned above i knew of, i just didn't realize the fight that a lot of the people i know have to stay on their lands and work it they way they see fit.... Does any of that make sense? I pretty much just rambled... my bad
 

Jogeephus

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 17, 2006
Messages
24,228
Reaction score
0
Location
South Georgia
I've only had experience with two NGO's.

I was a founding member of an NGO whose intent was to do research and offer extension-like information to others. In the beginning the members were down to earth, like-minded and practical till the group hired what turned out to be an academician treehugger and the group transformed itself into a political government money grovelling outfit that only serves itself and not the purpose which it was founded.

The second NGO I'm familiar with was a group my son's classmate joined. He is a card-carrying man-bun wearing die-hard liberal. A social justice crusader of the highest order. I've never met anyone like him before and to be honest - he intrigued me greatly because I never knew anyone who could be so retarded and not be in a padded cell. The group he joined purpose was to help the starving children in India by teaching them how to grow organic vegetables. After arriving in India he soon realized he could rent a house on the beach and have a maid and a cook come in every day and a yoga master come twice a week and this would cost him next to nothing. So he and his girlfriend spent less than six thousand dollars on a year long vacation and become yoga masters while exploiting the very people they had vowed to help. Like I say, I find this type self serving hypocrisy intriguing because I just don't know how one could sleep at night yet to listen to their hubris you would think they invented water. Update: He is now living in his mother's house but he did make it to Atlanta a few months ago to protest Trump. I guess he couldn't resist a paycheck from Soros.
 

Banjo

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 26, 2011
Messages
1,393
Reaction score
139
Location
Ky
FiveOaksFarmGA":2f8utp84 said:
I looked into one of those USDA microloans once for an equipment purchase. They wanted more info than the banks, interest rate was higher, and processing time was in excess of 100 days. Highly ineffective for business purposes, so used NGO (John Deere Financial) to pay for the purchase with 0% interest. Have heard of others that have had good use of USDA loans, but not beneficial in my experience. Rarely does government solve a problem.

The best equipment loan source I've found is Farm Credits Ag Direct program....most bigger dealers are set up with them. Almost too easy. Couple of days and your in business. You do need 20% down however.
 

littletom

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 6, 2015
Messages
1,043
Reaction score
16
Location
southern Ky
State university's do a ton of research to help the farmer. Some is unrealistic to use on a farm as can be cost prohibitive. Other is great and really helpful. They also do a lot of chemical testing and help with labeling for crop safety. The label is the law. In some crops they do a lot of variety research and development. Now this is not all tax payer money as much of it is industry donations.
 

FiveOaksFarmGA

Active member
Joined
Mar 25, 2017
Messages
43
Reaction score
0
As far as conservation, I do get a great benefit from the State of Georgia, whereas I agreed not to develop my land for the next 10 years and I get a property tax reduction. That was easy. Have never had good luck with anything in the Federal realm.
 

FiveOaksFarmGA

Active member
Joined
Mar 25, 2017
Messages
43
Reaction score
0
Banjo":2np5qyk2 said:
FiveOaksFarmGA":2np5qyk2 said:
I looked into one of those USDA microloans once for an equipment purchase. They wanted more info than the banks, interest rate was higher, and processing time was in excess of 100 days. Highly ineffective for business purposes, so used NGO (John Deere Financial) to pay for the purchase with 0% interest. Have heard of others that have had good use of USDA loans, but not beneficial in my experience. Rarely does government solve a problem.

The best equipment loan source I've found is Farm Credits Ag Direct program....most bigger dealers are set up with them. Almost too easy. Couple of days and your in business. You do need 20% down however.

Yeah I looked at our local Ag Credit sources, and they all wanted huge down payments and process similar to a mortgage or business loan. John Deere gave me $0 down, 0% for 60 months (could have went 72) and nearly instant approval with just a car loan type of application.
 

Banjo

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 26, 2011
Messages
1,393
Reaction score
139
Location
Ky
FiveOaksFarmGA":1ix7t29m said:
Banjo":1ix7t29m said:
FiveOaksFarmGA":1ix7t29m said:
I looked into one of those USDA microloans once for an equipment purchase. They wanted more info than the banks, interest rate was higher, and processing time was in excess of 100 days. Highly ineffective for business purposes, so used NGO (John Deere Financial) to pay for the purchase with 0% interest. Have heard of others that have had good use of USDA loans, but not beneficial in my experience. Rarely does government solve a problem.

The best equipment loan source I've found is Farm Credits Ag Direct program....most bigger dealers are set up with them. Almost too easy. Couple of days and your in business. You do need 20% down however.

Yeah I looked at our local Ag Credit sources, and they all wanted huge down payments and process similar to a mortgage or business loan. John Deere gave me $0 down, 0% for 60 months (could have went 72) and nearly instant approval with just a car loan type of application.

Did you have to buy JD equipment or do they finance anything?
 

FiveOaksFarmGA

Active member
Joined
Mar 25, 2017
Messages
43
Reaction score
0
Banjo":1ybz4w5x said:
FiveOaksFarmGA":1ybz4w5x said:
Banjo":1ybz4w5x said:
The best equipment loan source I've found is Farm Credits Ag Direct program....most bigger dealers are set up with them. Almost too easy. Couple of days and your in business. You do need 20% down however.

Yeah I looked at our local Ag Credit sources, and they all wanted huge down payments and process similar to a mortgage or business loan. John Deere gave me $0 down, 0% for 60 months (could have went 72) and nearly instant approval with just a car loan type of application.

Did you have to buy JD equipment or do they finance anything?

They finance anything the dealer sells. New JD and Kuhn. They also finance any used equipment of any brand that they have in inventory at extremely low rates (1.9% for 60). I typically have used my Credit Union for other equipment needs. The whole point of me ever using 0% financing is to use the free money, keep cash available, and reduce the need for repairs by buying new equipment. If I have to put 20% down, then I'll just pay cash for something used to get the job done. I have relationships with our Ag Credit services as well, just like the treatment and speed of business that I receive at the dealer and Credit Union better, so I use them the most.
 

FiveOaksFarmGA

Active member
Joined
Mar 25, 2017
Messages
43
Reaction score
0
Jogeephus":9hjjbmil said:
I've only had experience with two NGO's.

I was a founding member of an NGO whose intent was to do research and offer extension-like information to others. In the beginning the members were down to earth, like-minded and practical till the group hired what turned out to be an academician treehugger and the group transformed itself into a political government money grovelling outfit that only serves itself and not the purpose which it was founded.

The second NGO I'm familiar with was a group my son's classmate joined. He is a card-carrying man-bun wearing die-hard liberal. A social justice crusader of the highest order. I've never met anyone like him before and to be honest - he intrigued me greatly because I never knew anyone who could be so retarded and not be in a padded cell. The group he joined purpose was to help the starving children in India by teaching them how to grow organic vegetables. After arriving in India he soon realized he could rent a house on the beach and have a maid and a cook come in every day and a yoga master come twice a week and this would cost him next to nothing. So he and his girlfriend spent less than six thousand dollars on a year long vacation and become yoga masters while exploiting the very people they had vowed to help. Like I say, I find this type self serving hypocrisy intriguing because I just don't know how one could sleep at night yet to listen to their hubris you would think they invented water. Update: He is now living in his mother's house but he did make it to Atlanta a few months ago to protest Trump. I guess he couldn't resist a paycheck from Soros.

Dude.. you and I should grab a beer sometime. :tiphat:
 

Latest posts

Top