VtMapleGal
Well-known member
First pic is our simmental heifer. Second is our new red angus heifer (born in oct) and the third is my Rocky Mountain horse (didnt want him to feel jealous).
VtMapleGal":30jo8cih said:feel free to post your opinions.
cow_crazy_101 -cow_crazy_101":y77e675q said:VtMapleGal":y77e675q said:feel free to post your opinions.
They look skinny, the red angus could be lower in her hook and deeper in her rear flank and is bull necked..The Simmy looks over at the knees, sickly hocked, and "bull" headed, but with a better picture u could get better opoians..They do have some muscle. This is just my opioan, Bez , Dun , Alice??? Are you going to show them???
cow_crazy_101":1whuitwz said:VtMapleGal":1whuitwz said:feel free to post your opinions.
They look skinny, the red angus could be lower in her hook and deeper in her rear flank and is bull necked..The Simmy looks over at the knees, sickly hocked, and "bull" headed, but with a better picture u could get better opoians..They do have some muscle. This is just my opioan, Bez , Dun , Alice??? Are you going to show them???
DOC HARRIS":q9nbk0sq said:cow_crazy_101 -cow_crazy_101":q9nbk0sq said:VtMapleGal":q9nbk0sq said:feel free to post your opinions.
They look skinny, the red angus could be lower in her hook and deeper in her rear flank and is bull necked..The Simmy looks over at the knees, sickly hocked, and "bull" headed, but with a better picture u could get better opoians..They do have some muscle. This is just my opioan, Bez , Dun , Alice??? Are you going to show them???
Under the given circumstances, I think you are being a little exploitative with your "101" Judging training. Your terms are not legitimately descriptive - "look skinny" ( I would ask - -"compared to - what??) "lower in her hook", (I am unfamiliar with this descriptive terminology), "over at the knees", (do you mean "Buck-kneed?") "sickly hocked" (the term is "sickle hocked", but from this angle it is impossible to determine that characteristic. She 'appears' a little "cow-hocked" but that is because she is a calf). As a matter of fact - they are BOTH calves, and as such, their phenotype will change incrementally and exponentially as their genetic potential dictates in relationship to the proper care they may be given by their Dams milk, and expected future weaning growth, and potential Yearling maturation. "Bull-headed" is subjective, and I disagree with your assumption. At this age, the phrase is too harsh to be definitive. Also, at this age, the physiology of the Red Angus calf has not developed enough to be considered lacking in the depth of her rear flank, which frankly, in this picture, she is NOT shallow in the rear flank.
And, parenthetically, the term is not "opioan". It is "opinion".
I would suggest that you peruse your "Judging Terminology" a little more carefully, and intensify your visual appraisal skills. It is very difficult to accurately determine optimally desirable phenotypic traits and characteristics in a young, suckling calf. It is always advisable to understand that a photograph of an individual is never adequate to successfully visually appraise a subject. The camera angles will ALWAYS distort reality, and the fore-shortening effect will mis-represent the true proportion of all body parts, particularly the head-on view.
DOC HARRIS
cow_crazy_101":1sxly6l8 said:DOC HARRIS":1sxly6l8 said:cow_crazy_101 -cow_crazy_101":1sxly6l8 said:VtMapleGal":1sxly6l8 said:feel free to post your opinions.
They look skinny, the red angus could be lower in her hook and deeper in her rear flank and is bull necked..The Simmy looks over at the knees, sickly hocked, and "bull" headed, but with a better picture u could get better opoians..They do have some muscle. This is just my opioan, Bez , Dun , Alice??? Are you going to show them???
Under the given circumstances, I think you are being a little exploitative with your "101" Judging training. Your terms are not legitimately descriptive - "look skinny" ( I would ask - -"compared to - what??) "lower in her hook", (I am unfamiliar with this descriptive terminology), "over at the knees", (do you mean "Buck-kneed?") "sickly hocked" (the term is "sickle hocked", but from this angle it is impossible to determine that characteristic. She 'appears' a little "cow-hocked" but that is because she is a calf). As a matter of fact - they are BOTH calves, and as such, their phenotype will change incrementally and exponentially as their genetic potential dictates in relationship to the proper care they may be given by their Dams milk, and expected future weaning growth, and potential Yearling maturation. "Bull-headed" is subjective, and I disagree with your assumption. At this age, the phrase is too harsh to be definitive. Also, at this age, the physiology of the Red Angus calf has not developed enough to be considered lacking in the depth of her rear flank, which frankly, in this picture, she is NOT shallow in the rear flank.
And, parenthetically, the term is not "opioan". It is "opinion".
I would suggest that you peruse your "Judging Terminology" a little more carefully, and intensify your visual appraisal skills. It is very difficult to accurately determine optimally desirable phenotypic traits and characteristics in a young, suckling calf. It is always advisable to understand that a photograph of an individual is never adequate to successfully visually appraise a subject. The camera angles will ALWAYS distort reality, and the fore-shortening effect will mis-represent the true proportion of all body parts, particularly the head-on view.
DOC HARRIS
I stand corrected. 101 does not mean anything, just needed something put at the end of my username, and i happened to think of " zoey 101 " at the time and thought it went well with cow_crazy_101. And I was just putting what i thought down, If i had known you would mock my spelling and my words,{had a really long day, My dad went to the hospital monday} cut and butcher everthing i wrote i would not have put anything down. No where did I say that i was "101" Judging training." I am not. The terms i used are stilled used at shows i attened sometimes. Hope you have a good day!
hillsdown":veed9elx said:Cow Crazy 101 I also thought you were being a little mean and critical with your comments.However now that you have said what a difficult week it has been for you that is completely understandable as the critique seemed completely out of character for you you usually have nothing but nice comments of encouragement.Hopefully VtMapleGal didn't get offended.It is brave enough of someone to even post pics let alone ask for opinions.And about the spelling until there is an automatic spell check available when posting I plead the 5th and I myself have never claimed to be a typist.
I hope your week is going better and that your father is doing well and feeling better.
hillsdown":ipqvqi0m said:Alice that is what I meant ;but also she seems to be close to quite a few of you on the board especially you ;and if it has been a really hard and troubling couple of days for her I hope that she knows that she can talk to most anyone here.I personally think it's great that a gal her age is on this forum and giving advice(good) as much as some of the old timers that have been with cattle for 40+ years.
DOC HARRIS":1iwnhv5h said:Cow_Crazy_101-
I am replying to this quote: - DOC HARRIS
" I stand corrected. 101 does not mean anything, just needed something put at the end of my username, and i happened to think of " zoey 101 " at the time and thought it went well with cow_crazy_101. And I was just putting what i thought down, If i had known you would mock my spelling and my words,{had a really long day, My dad went to the hospital monday} cut and butcher everthing i wrote i would not have put anything down. No where did I say that i was "101" Judging training." I am not. The terms i used are stilled used at shows i attened sometimes. Hope you have a good day!"
You have completely misunderstood my intentions when I commented about your post! I was NOT "mocking" your spelling and your words, - only your terminology in Beef Judging, which was meant in a helpful manner. Don't take offense. The only "mocking" I do is that of Liberal Left-Wing Democrats :devil2: and their Fellow-Travelers in the News Media, which I do quite well, and with gusto and disdain!
Likewise, I did not "cut and butcher" everything that you wrote. I was merely attempting to help you with your vocation (avocation?) which is part and parcel of being a good Beef Producer. Knowing what to look for, and how to express what you see is crucial in being a success in ANY business, and Beef Production is a BU$INE$$ , and the more professional you can present yourself to other people, the more they will respect you.
Enough comment on this subject!
I am sorry about your father. I hope that he will recover from his problems. I have - and will - pray for him and a speedy recovery!
DOC HARRIS