NEW HOLLAND t4105 VS JOHN DEERE5105m

[TANK30705]

Any recommendations on the new holland tractors or john deere in 100hp category? The 2 listed in the subject are what I'm considering. Got a heck of a good price on the new holland. So far JD is pricier. Any info would be greatly appreciated.

 

[B&M Farms]

Any recommendations on the new holland tractors or john deere in 100hp category? The 2 listed in the subject are what I'm considering. Got a heck of a good price on the new holland. So far JD is pricier. Any info would be greatly appreciated.

I would look up their specs and see which one weighs more, has the bigger hydraulic pump, the most PTO horsepower and a few other things before I made a decision just based on price. There is a pretty good chance the JD is a better tractor for the money.

 

[Red Bull Breeder]

There is also a good chance that the green paint job is just a little more costly.

 

[Red Bull Breeder]

Myself I would try and stay away form the tier 4 engines. From what I have been told they drink fuel blue or green.

 

[highgrit]

But they don't smoke. What a bunch of B.S.

 

[Red Bull Breeder]

Highgrit just try you one blue or green or orange with new emmissions. The deere is gonna burn more fuel anyway.

 

[SmokinM]

The 5105m isn't tier4. I would also say that is the way you want to go pollution control on a diesel is never as good as not having it! My preference is the Deere. The power reverser is smoother, where the controls are placed are a huge difference, a little more hydraulics, better visibility for the loader when raised,and those m series tractors are beefy and very well balanced. New Hollands are not bad tractors just not quite on the same level as the Deere tho. Just MHO.

 

[Red Bull Breeder]

Depends on if you are buying the fuel or me. you buy it I don't care, I buy it I do care.

 

[Red Bull Breeder]

Blind man should not read without glasses Highgrit.

 

[highgrit]

Redbull, it's crazy what we let the EPA do to us. They all burn to much fuel, but you might as well look good doing it.

 

[Red Bull Breeder]

Look for models without tier 4 still in stock. Never thought I would buy another Kubota but I did, got the m108 with out tier 4. Like the darn pretty good, it does a decent job of what I do.

 

[hillbilly beef man]

I was reading that Deere was going to be required to use DEF fluid to meet epa regs. Can you do a def delete on one like you can on a pickup?

 

[TANK30705]

Well everyone says JD is the best. I pretty much agree.
I would like a JD 5105M but none in my area. Gonna have to travel couple miles at least.
Was offered a good trade on my old tractor and a 5100e but I am worried an economy tractor won't last.The new holland is a massive tractor and is suppose to weigh 8400pds, so I'm thinking its not an economy tractor. Its setup about like the deere in the cab.
Opinions???

 

[James T]

Looks like the specs are pretty comparable to me. It might come down to how far away the parts people are, warranty, standard equipment versus optional and ease of operation. I learned the other day that extendable arm links are optional on many John Deere's. Thought all manufactures had them as standard equipment.

 

[bigbull338]

tank see im the other way.i will not look at consider or trade for a JD tractor.i traded tractors in july an my brother wanted me to trade for a jd an i wouldnt consider it.traded for another kubota.