Is this true?

hillsdown

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 31, 2006
Messages
9,930
City & State/Province
Alberta, Canada
when a heifer can have the first one unassisted, she'll have all the later calves unassisted as well barring twins and other freak situations.

I read this in one of the breeds threads and it got me thinking .

This year I had to use a calf puller on two cows that had a calf unassisted as heifers, same bull this year and it was both the third calf.
Now as I stated before our birth weights were up about 10% this year than last but I was wonder if most people find this is true with their cows.

Have you found that if she has her first calf on her own that she will have all subsequent calves unassisted as well, foreseeing you don't use a huge birth weight bull.
 
true for the most part but false. so many factors. birthweight, structure (large head, shoulders, hips etc), etc, etc.

i had two second calvers this year that had problems.
 
Beefy":1p9pmqv6 said:
true for the most part but false. so many factors. birthweight, structure (large head, shoulders, hips etc), etc, etc.

i had two second calvers this year that had problems.

Exactly. I had a second calver just completely give up this year and had to pull a 75 lb. calf.

I have found with cattle, there is no such thing as never and always.
 
bandit80":ur3nqcpt said:
Beefy":ur3nqcpt said:
true for the most part but false. so many factors. birthweight, structure (large head, shoulders, hips etc), etc, etc.

i had two second calvers this year that had problems.

Exactly. I had a second calver just completely give up this year and had to pull a 75 lb. calf.

I have found with cattle, there is no such thing as never and always.

Oh Brother!!! Ain't that the truth!! :nod:
 
that statement is false.because anything can happen to cause a cow to have trouble cavling.you can have a calf coming backwards upside down twisted.an few other ways that might require a C-section.
 
bigbull338":yst2goj0 said:
that statement is false.because anything can happen to cause a cow to have trouble cavling.you can have a calf coming backwards upside down twisted.an few other ways that might require a C-section.

That is where this part comes into play of the statement..
barring twins and other freak situations.
we are excluding those anomalies in the equation.
 
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change.
That doesn;t even qualify as an OWT, it's just hogwash.
If a heifer calves unassisted we "assume" she'll be able to calve unassisted from then on. But the only thing that is dead bang certain in this business is that there is nothing that is dead bang certain
 
TNMasterBeefProducer":lyev19d4 said:
Attorney friend whom I turned onto Salers had a big ole black baldy cow give birth to a breach Salers calf unassisted and the calf was up before the mom got him cleaned off trying to nurse.
Sailed right thru it. ;-)
 
We have one cow that will be 12yo next year. Have not had a problem with her calving, so far. Have had cows that calved as heifers fine need a hand the next year. Dun is right, the only thing certain, is nothing is "normal".
 
dun":1b0c2rvy said:
That doesn;t even qualify as an OWT, it's just hogwash.
If a heifer calves unassisted we "assume" she'll be able to calve unassisted from then on. But the only thing that is dead bang certain in this business is that there is nothing that is dead bang certain

Since the original hogwash statement was made by me I'll elaborate....

Maybe I should have said when a heifer can have the first one unassisted, she'll GENERALLY have all the later calves unassisted as well barring twins and other freak situations if its a normal presentation

That being said, read the whole thread and put it in the context it was written. The discussion was about how to introduce a bigger BW bull into your herd through AI. If any of you feel those cows that struggled to have the first calf are the ideal candidates to use the higher BW bull on to improve your herd, go ahead, but its not the way I would do it and not what would advise anyone that asks me.

All this talk about pulling calves out of second calvers and older cows makes me wonder just how much dystocia you all have? I'll assist less than 10% of births out of heifers aged 22-25 months and I don't deliberately use calving bulls, that being said I avoid big BW bulls the same way I avoid extremely low BW bulls. I never (let's say seldom to be more PC) have to help a second calver and onwards unless its a malpresentation caused by twins trying to be born at the same time.

I corrected one malpresentation in a second calver this year (one foot back) I just corrected the presentation and before I could get the ropes on the feet the calf was born naturally.

As most on here know, I like my herefords wide and deep with lots of muscle, I am not afraid of masculine well muscled masculine shoulders on bulls, I want a wide broad chest on bulls, I like short broad masculine heads, a thick short neck, I like medium to medium heavy bone, I don't breed heifers to cow freshner bulls, according to most "experts" I am a calving disaster waiting to happen, the fact is my herd calves easily, my bulls in other herds causes no calving difficulty (actually much less than the bulls they used in the past) otherwise I won't have return customers.

I also want a slight slope from hooks to pins, width between the hooks and pins, I avoid tall leggy bulls, depth and extra capacity is not even negotiable in heifers to be retained, I don't chase extremes. I place alot of emphasis on correct shoulder structure.

I cull vigorously everything that don't calf unassisted or are lazy calvers, I believe that a registered heifer should be able to have a calf of breed average size with no problem ......and I don't need to pull calves out of mature cows.

If mature cows needs assistance calving normal presentations, you (generally speaking) need to re-evaluate your breeding and selection protocols.

But the only thing that is dead bang certain in this business is that there is nothing that is dead bang certain

Very true, that and the fact that if the goal is an argument, it will always be achieved.
 
FIGHT - FIGHT

The only context I took it in was that as was posted in this thread.
We occasioanlly what are classified as claving ease bulls, but I don;t hold it against them. As long as they have the other traits going for them, low BW would almost boil down to single trait selection. As I've said so often that I'm sure people are tired of reading it, I challenge the cows to raise a big calf not to birth a big calf.
 
I think that bull selection has a lot to do with calving ease. Some bulls have bigger calves than others. There is such a thing as a calf that is too big...
 
There is such a thing as a calf that is too big...

Totally agree, there is also such a thing as a cow that is just not build to calve easily, they should not be permitted to have an influence on the future generations in a herd.
 
KNERSIE":yce2isiw said:
dun":yce2isiw said:
That doesn;t even qualify as an OWT, it's just hogwash.
If a heifer calves unassisted we "assume" she'll be able to calve unassisted from then on. But the only thing that is dead bang certain in this business is that there is nothing that is dead bang certain

Since the original hogwash statement was made by me I'll elaborate....

Maybe I should have said when a heifer can have the first one unassisted, she'll GENERALLY have all the later calves unassisted as well barring twins and other freak situations if its a normal presentation

That being said, read the whole thread and put it in the context it was written. The discussion was about how to introduce a bigger BW bull into your herd through AI. If any of you feel those cows that struggled to have the first calf are the ideal candidates to use the higher BW bull on to improve your herd, go ahead, but its not the way I would do it and not what would advise anyone that asks me.

All this talk about pulling calves out of second calvers and older cows makes me wonder just how much dystocia you all have? I'll assist less than 10% of births out of heifers aged 22-25 months and I don't deliberately use calving bulls, that being said I avoid big BW bulls the same way I avoid extremely low BW bulls. I never (let's say seldom to be more PC) have to help a second calver and onwards unless its a malpresentation caused by twins trying to be born at the same time.

I corrected one malpresentation in a second calver this year (one foot back) I just corrected the presentation and before I could get the ropes on the feet the calf was born naturally.

As most on here know, I like my herefords wide and deep with lots of muscle, I am not afraid of masculine well muscled masculine shoulders on bulls, I want a wide broad chest on bulls, I like short broad masculine heads, a thick short neck, I like medium to medium heavy bone, I don't breed heifers to cow freshner bulls, according to most "experts" I am a calving disaster waiting to happen, the fact is my herd calves easily, my bulls in other herds causes no calving difficulty (actually much less than the bulls they used in the past) otherwise I won't have return customers.

I also want a slight slope from hooks to pins, width between the hooks and pins, I avoid tall leggy bulls, depth and extra capacity is not even negotiable in heifers to be retained, I don't chase extremes. I place alot of emphasis on correct shoulder structure.

I cull vigorously everything that don't calf unassisted or are lazy calvers, I believe that a registered heifer should be able to have a calf of breed average size with no problem ......and I don't need to pull calves out of mature cows.

If mature cows needs assistance calving normal presentations, you (generally speaking) need to re-evaluate your breeding and selection protocols.

But the only thing that is dead bang certain in this business is that there is nothing that is dead bang certain

Very true, that and the fact that if the goal is an argument, it will always be achieved.

There's a blueprint that everyone can use! :tiphat:

George
 
Sorry, I thought I had posted the link, I guess it did not paste.

I found the discussion very interesting as I was considering the same as ILH as there are a couple of AI bulls with quite large birth weight epds that I have been considering using on my larger framed older cows.

After going through the last six years of beef records and 10 years of Holstein dairy records of have to say the statement is very true. If you take out anomalies such as malpresentations/twins etc.

With our dairy we belonged to the young sire program and you never did know what you would get because they were all unproven bulls.
So they were used only on older cows and even with some huge birth weights 99% of the cows were unassisted ,and had healthy deliveries if they were presented properly and not twins.

If you follow the plan/rules that Knersie uses considering the frame/structure of an animal and have a proper nutrition and mineral program I think that this could definitely be a rule of thumb ,barring the exceptions and that weather (if you calve in -40 weather anything can happen) sometimes plays in birth weights.
 
well yeah i guess if you take out ALL of the factors that make a statement false than its true...
 
I read the original as I read Proverbs. Proverbs are not promises nor are they guarantees. They are sayings or adages that are generally true.
 
Chris H":2hjsar2l said:
I read the original as I read Proverbs. Proverbs are not promises nor are they guarantees. They are sayings or adages that are generally true.

At last some common sense prevails!
 

Latest posts

Back
Top