I don't really know much about the bottom half of his pedigree, but like the top half. Knowing what you have in your tank and what you have used last year, I think you are certainly looking in the right direction, especially if you have a few females that don't milk all that well. (Or daughters out of cows that could be heavier milkers)
Phenotypically I can't really fault him except he has a little more sheath than you'd normally find in a herefordbull. Good polled head, good eyes, good hindquarter (especially for a bull with a +25 for milk), nice bone and a little more angle in the hock than the typical show bull and possible a little more slope in the rump than your typical show bull not that I think that its a fault at all.
I prefer him over Rib Eye going on the photos I have to make that comparison, if that answers your question.