Handloading Accident

inyati13

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 17, 2011
Messages
6,707
City & State/Province
Kentucky, Outer Bluegrass
It was Casper, WY about 1983. I was at the Poison Spider Range west of town.

The range had concrete benches and overhead roof. The roof was supported by mild steel round stock. Welded and fabricated on site. There were about 8 benches. Each end of the roofed area was enclosed with plank siding. I was on the far left shooting a hunting rifle. I was the only one there until a guy comes in to shoot his brand new Smith and Wesson .44 magnum. He explained that he had just started handloading.

Pistol powders burn at a rapid rate compared to a rifle powder like H4831. I cannot remember but he said he was using something like Bullseye or Unique.

He was about 4 benches to my right. He was preparing to shoot and as a matter of safety I watch him. I am preparing to shoot. He is standing up and is getting prepared to fire downrange. I settle into my rifle and I hear his gun go off and hear a thud in the wall on my left. The man is screaming for help. I get up go over where he is on the ground. He has blood pouring from a cut above his right eye right at the scalp line.

The only thought I had afterward was that he had triple charged his handloads. The top strap was broken in front of the hammer and was sticking straight up. About 2/3 of the cyclinder was forced down. The chamber where the round was fired broke apart into two pieces shearing off at the adjoining chambers. The left piece went with in a foot of my head and was buried in the planks to the left of my bench. The other chunk of cyclinder went up, hit the mild steel roundstock supporting the roof above his head and bounced back and cut a deep long wound in the mans head. He got up and seemed OK but put together his things and left. That might have been as close as I have come to being killed by a projectile.
 
The basis for my thought that this was due to a triple charge is this: When I started loading pistol calibers like .357 magnum and .44 magnum, if you are using some the the fastest burning pistol powders, they use about 25 % of the case capacity for a full maximum load. I thought the guy may have thought you fill the entire case up. If he did, he was set to have this kind of episode.
 
I had a customer do the same thing but his was caused by not being able to read a straight line. He used Bullseye when the charge he was looking at was for unique and he loaded 38 cases with the amount for a 357 mag. That's the reason for the common sense rule of never shooting someone elses reloads.
 
dun":1aefq806 said:
I had a customer do the same thing but his was caused by not being able to read a straight line. He used Bullseye when the charge he was looking at was for unique and he loaded 38 cases with the amount for a 357 mag. That's the reason for the common sense rule of never shooting someone elses reloads.


I got my lesson in shooting someone else's reloads about 25 years ago. My brother gave me 3 boxes of .357 magnum that a friend of his father in laws had given his cousins aunts uncle or something like that.

I pulled the trigger and thought I blew my Colt up, It appeared to be undamaged. But my hand felt kind of tingly. I went back in the house and got my rcbs bullet puller and disassembled all the loads, saved the bullets. And never shot anyone's but my own reloads since. I have no idea what was in them, but they were hot...
 
inyati13":20wno89m said:
The basis for my thought that this was due to a triple charge is this: When I started loading pistol calibers like .357 magnum and .44 magnum, if you are using some the the fastest burning pistol powders, they use about 25 % of the case capacity for a full maximum load. I thought the guy may have thought you fill the entire case up. If he did, he was set to have this kind of episode.

One of the many reasons I like Trail Boss for my loads.
I load a lot with Unique, HP 38 and H110 as well got to pay attention.
I don't think HP 38 load will fill 25% of the case.
 
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change.
tamarack":32q70c9n said:
I don't know much about pistol reloading but it is also bad to reload rifle cartridges less than min as could detonate with same results.

H4895 is probably the most versatile and there is a lot of data for reduced loads without getting into trouble as you mentioned.
http://www.hodgdon.com/PDF/H4895%20Redu ... 0Loads.pdf
 

Latest posts

Back
Top