Old Timer said: "And that is what I save my second cutting and good alfalfa hay for is after calving begins... In this cold weather- the cows actually get more heat from grass hay and straw then they do from good alfalfa as its too washy...."
this is exactly correct. Yes, you need some protein, YOU NEED BALANCE. But a cow only NEEDS about maybe a 10-12% protein grass hay to stay in good condition. I'm not a nutritionist (hubby was) but that's about what I remember. We feed baleage, mostly grass hay w/ clover - usually runs around 15-16% protein. Little richer than they NEED, but we calve starting in Jan, so after they calve, they really utilize the protein. Yes, I feel our BW's are higher than they might be on another farm, but no calving problems & my cows are usually cycling 30-45 days after calving.