angus9259":2xh87cm5 said:
jcarkie":2xh87cm5 said:
The fewer you have you tend to baby and over feed when you get more you treat them like cattle.
Again, I have no idea how this applies to this thread. Unless you're suggesting that if you just leave your cattle alone and don't "baby" (whatever that means) then you won't have any problems with them and thereby never need to check them for illness or injury?
Anyone can have a run of bad luck.
The statement kind of does apply in theory, but I can say I've never practised that theory. I cull on health problems without asking too hard why the health issues arose, but I *do* get out there and observe the cows at calving and deal with problems asap and use whatever means I've got to hand to prevent problems.
Again, I never got to the point of practising this, but I managed an organic farm for a while and one of the theories was that some cows just aren't suited to being farmed organically. You hear farmers saying they have no problems with their cattle, but then you start hearing the stories about how terrible the first few years are, watching all these 'unsuited' cattle turn their feet up or get culled.
Which is basically what happened in my herd, but I never really thought it was about the cattle being unsuited to the environment, I was having to cull that ones that could least handle being starved because a) the soil fertility was run down to the point the farm couldn't grow grass and b) I'd been lied to about how many cows the farm could graze and what had happened to the previous dairy herd on the farm (it died of starvation).
Still considering this theory of herd adaptation, I have this big logical problem with putting 'survival of the fittest' into practise and creating a herd that never has any issues with its environment. And that's the percentage of the genetics that I control - with bulls bought in from other herds, or AI, I select from 50% (the cows) for my specific environment and their suitability for that environment is continually being diluted in their daughters by bought-in sires *unless* I choose to breed from the best within the herd and forgo outside genetics. Of course picking bulls from a similar environment will help, but it's not equivalent to selecting bulls from the best within the herd.
From what I've read, pursuing a 'survival of the fittest' philosophy does work, eventually. Obviously there are still losses, but they are not deemed important or too numerous by the cattle owner.
I don't see how you can push above average in anything - if that is your goal - by leaving nature to run your cattle operation.
On the other hand, nature is far wiser than we sometimes give her credit for. You saved the mother of the twins, and likely saved the cow with mastitis
but nature can also work in unexpected ways. Did you know that nearly half of all mastitis cases 'self-cure' thanks to the cow's own immune function, and that dairymen who treat every case with antibiotics tend to presume it was the antibiotic that worked? I had a cow down for three days a year ago, got the vet to her twice the vets were saying it was milk fever & I've seen tons of milk fever & was saying that's not the main problem. She got up on her own, the day before her blood results came back, without ever having been treated for the infection that was evident in the bloods.
1 in 20 malpresentations sounds high, but it doesn't really get much less than that - I pull about the same number a lot of years, though this year I've only had one for 130 calved, another year it might be ten. Haven't counted up the stillbirths this year but I know we lost a couple to bad weather, found one heifer licking off a dead one, she's fine, you just never know with those ones if it was backwards or already dead or just a bit too long calving, even with regular checks. I like to think I've done well if there's no more than six calves leave the farm as skins, but in reality there's nothing I do or don't do that changes the outcomes of these ones. Maybe if I looked at them every five minutes instead of every five hours...
You're definitely due a change in luck.