Michelle, thanks for the reply and explanation.
From my perspective, I didn't see where the original poster's calf had true scours.
You said, " Calf scours will have a foul odor, and be loose/runny, calf may also produce a bubly/faomy defecation that is runny. Give calf Poly Serum 75/150cc sub Q to PREVENT scours." (I capitalized the word prevent.)
I agree with you that calves on milk replacer are a little more touchy to raise and may need some extra care, but I don't agree with giving antibiotics to prevent scours.
The probios might be beneficial to a bottle calf. I have always understood calves nibble on solids and develop the needed bacteria from those solids. By the time they are having to rely on solids for nutrition, they have developed the needed bacteria.
It's not only people who are using antibiotics unnecessarily. Residues of antibiotics in our feed, as well as other hormones and chemicals are assaulting our bodies and our environment. Plus, subtherapeutic treatment of animal disease is leaving the strong bacteria alive, while killing off the weak bacteria.
I just think we, as farmers, need to be a little more careful in making the decision to administer antibiotics.
> If you have true scours you treat
> with antibiotics or lose the calf
> in serious cases,
> When you have a calf on milk
> replacer and not on a cow, the gut
> does not get the natural
> inoculation of beneficial bacteria
> needed to process forage, thus by
> giving the probios to a bottle
> calf you will increase the calves
> ability to begin to digest solid
> feed stuffs by starting the
> population of desired bacteria.
> Think about it, it is very
> logical, and I agree Antibiotics
> are to heavily used by people who
> do not know how or when to use
> them, but when needed to treat a
> sick calf or any other animal, I
> say go for it and try and save
> them if it is feasable and
> realistic.