Yes, I would. Chances are our two don't have it, since they are in a 40+ acre field with the 2 other heifers that were subject to Johne's. Before we put them together, the other heifers were in a field of 60+ acres with about 20 cows with the one that definitely has Johne's.
We aren't taking that chance though. Our luck, ours did get it, we bring them home and then 2 years from now, BAM!. We are taking them to the sale barn, as slaughter only.
A buyer needs to ask for a Johne's test. But now, since I've learned that the tests aren't that accurate, especially for young heifers, the test wouldn't help anyone.
It is just a bad situation all around. It makes you wonder if the cows you are buying have ever been subject to this disease. Kind of makes me a little panicky. I guess it all comes down to honesty and trusting your neighbor until you are burned.