Nothing like a "Black Hereford" thread to stir up things at CT!
Breed definition -
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breed So, is Black Hereford a breed by this definition?
The "black" comes from Registered Angus, so I guess the purity of the "black" is dependent on the purity of of the Black Angus that the Black Hereford breed was bred up from. Same goes for the Hereford!
Some of us that have been around long enough to watch other breeds as they were being "bred up" realize that the Black Herefords are suffering much of the same denigration that the Chars, Simmis, and others suffered as they were being bred up in this country.
I've heard the ABHA CEO, Craig Ludwig, say from an auction podium that the founding breeders realize that the Black Hereford breed still has a "ways to go"! There still aren't a whole lot of cattle out there that will qualify as being purebred according to the association standards(black and 7/8 Hereford blood). But I've been watching this breed for a while, now, and I strongly believe that they are making progress.
Massey pictured what could be the 2 best Black Hereford breeding bulls in the population at the time they were put into service. In either the traditional Hereford or Angus population, these bulls might not even be considered good enough quality to use as registered seedstock, but they were/are the best that's available to those wanting to breed Black Herefords.
So, like Knersie, I view the restriction of being only able to use cattle from the ABHA registry as ONE of the parents in the breeding up process as a real handicap to the breed's progress. And, no doubt, it is a protectionist move that assures that the founding breeders will share greatly in the premium that results from others that want to get involved.
But, through the use of the RIGHT registered HEREFORD seedstock being infused into the breed, improvement in the Black Hereford breed is going to come. And, as long as the black hided cattle continue to bring a premium at the sale barn, there is going to be demand for cattle that can bring the good qualities that Hereford cattle possess and also can assure a black hide.
The only thing that I could see derailing this effort would be for the Black Angus Association to start DNA testing feeder/fed cattle and requiring that 50% Black Angus blood be in the cattle that qualify for the designation/premium. But I've been told that demand for Angus beef is so high that the likelihood of that happening is remote.